The functions of law and its role in social life

🇵🇱 Polski
The functions of law and its role in social life

📚 Based on

Die Lehre von dem richtigen Rechte

👤 About the Author

Friedrich Carl Von Savigny

Introduction

Law is much more than a collection of rules. It is the foundation of social order, a tool for seeking justice, and a mechanism for resolving conflicts. Its role evolves with civilization, reflecting the values and aspirations of a community. This article analyzes the key functions of law, from its philosophical foundations to its pragmatic applications, demonstrating how it shapes human relationships and legitimizes power, thereby becoming a universal language of social order.

Law: Philosophical Foundations of Justice

At the core of legal thought lies the idea of justice. Theorists such as Rudolf Stammler viewed law as a tool for harmonizing the goals of the individual and the community. However, its role extends beyond ideals. Gustav Radbruch, in his famous formula, set a limit: grossly unjust law loses its binding force, underscoring its moral dimension. The sociology of law goes further, indicating that the sources of norms lie within society itself. Eugen Ehrlich described this as living law – the actual rules of conduct that exist independently of legal codes. Similarly, the Historical School (Savigny) saw law as an expression of the spirit of the people (Volksgeist), emerging from tradition. Even anthropologists, studying primitive societies, confirmed that norms are essential for maintaining group cohesion.

Law Establishes Order and Mediates Conflicts

The most fundamental function of law is to create social order and control. It transforms chaos into a predictable structure, providing a sense of security. Law also serves as an institutional moderator in unavoidable disputes. Instead of force, it offers civilized procedures for resolving conflicts, which Rudolf von Ihering described as a perpetual "struggle for law." Key to stability is predictability. As Oliver Wendell Holmes noted, law allows for forecasting the consequences of actions, which is the foundation of planning and social trust. Without this characteristic, economic and social development is impossible.

Law: Legitimization of Power and Protection Against Abuse

Law plays a crucial role in its relationship with power. On one hand, it legitimizes power, providing it with a framework and authority. On the other hand, it protects against its abuses, which is the foundation of the rule of law and the idea of the separation of powers. From a pragmatic perspective, law is a tool for social engineering. As Roscoe Pound argued, it serves to consciously balance conflicting interests within society. Hans Kelsen emphasized the systemic nature of law in his pure theory of law. He described law as a coherent, hierarchical structure of norms, whose strength lies in formal logic rather than appeals to morality.

Conclusion

Law is a multidimensional phenomenon that connects the world of facts and values. Serving functions from ensuring order to legitimizing power, it becomes a universal language of social order. Ultimately, as Jerzy Wróblewski put it, "law does not exist for its own sake, but for humanity." It remains an arena of tension between ideal and reality. Can we build a just society without losing sight of its subservient role to the individual? In these constant struggles lies the true strength and dynamism of law.

📄 Full analysis available in PDF

📖 Glossary

Prawo właściwe (richtiges Recht)
Koncepcja prawa, która wykracza poza formalne przepisy, dążąc do harmonizacji celów indywidualnych i społecznych w oparciu o ideę, że człowiek zawsze funkcjonuje w relacji do innych.
Jurysprudencja interesów
Kierunek w teorii prawa, który postrzega prawo jako narzędzie do rozstrzygania i równoważenia sprzecznych interesów w społeczeństwie, zamiast realizowania abstrakcyjnych ideałów.
Wolne badania naukowe (libre recherche scientifique)
Metoda interpretacji prawa, która pozwala prawnikom wykraczać poza skodyfikowane źródła i sięgać do faktów społecznych, wartości moralnych oraz wiedzy interdyscyplinarnej w poszukiwaniu sprawiedliwych rozwiązań.
Normatywna siła faktyczności/faktu
Koncepcja opisująca proces, w którym realne układy sił społecznych lub faktyczne instytucje z czasem przekształcają się w obowiązujące normy prawne, zyskując moc wiążącą.
Prawo żywe (living law)
Pojęcie odnoszące się do faktycznych norm zachowania, które spontanicznie tworzą się i funkcjonują w społeczeństwie, często niezależnie od oficjalnych kodeksów i ustaw.
Duch narodu (Volksgeist)
Koncepcja, według której prawo nie jest tworzone arbitralnie, lecz organicznie wyrasta z tradycji, zwyczajów i zbiorowej świadomości danej wspólnoty, odzwierciedlając jej unikalną tożsamość.
Inżynieria społeczna
Metaforyczne określenie roli prawa jako narzędzia świadomego kształtowania i dostosowywania relacji międzyludzkich oraz rozwiązywania konfliktów interesów w społeczeństwie.
Czysta nauka prawa (Reine Rechtslehre)
Teoria prawa, która dąży do oddzielenia norm prawnych od moralnych i politycznych, przedstawiając prawo jako hierarchicznie uporządkowany system, którego moc obowiązująca wynika z wewnętrznej spójności, a nie z zewnętrznych wartości.

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the main functions of law according to the text?
The text distinguishes four main functions of law: seeking justice, maintaining social order, resolving conflicts, and ensuring predictability. Law is therefore both an ideal and a practical tool for stabilizing collective life.
How does law fulfill the function of justice?
Law fulfills the function of justice, providing people with a tool to seek just solutions, even when the letter of the code is insufficient. It respects individuality and participation in community, and it evolves with the development of civilization, reflecting its current needs and values.
What does Eugen Ehrlich's concept of "living law" mean?
Eugen Ehrlich's concept of "living law" refers to actual norms of behavior that spontaneously arise and function within society, independently of official codes. Ehrlich argued that the center of legal development lies within society itself, and that statutes and judgments are merely a secondary reflection of these actual rules.
How did Roscoe Pound define the role of law in the context of social conflicts?
Roscoe Pound viewed law as a "tool of social engineering," whose primary function is to resolve inevitable conflicts of interest between individuals and groups. Law aligns conflicting claims with the overall scheme of community interests, enabling compromise and stable coexistence.
Why is predictability a key function of law?
Predictability is a key function of law because society cannot thrive in conditions of uncertainty. Law creates a framework within which individuals can rationally plan their actions, knowing the consequences of violating norms and their rights, which is the foundation of social order.
How does law differ from violence according to Max Weber?
According to Max Weber, law is a coercive technique that differs from violence in that it is applied according to rules. It gives society the ability to use force in an orderly and legitimate manner, transforming brute force into authority and ensuring stability.

Related Questions

🧠 Thematic Groups