Inclusive Hierarchy: A Mechanism for Social Integration
Hierarchy is a universal element of human societies that should not be equated solely with oppression. The key lies in the distinction between inclusive and stigmatizing hierarchies. In an inclusive system, subordination signifies entering a circle of care and responsibility, offering a clear path for aspiration and a way back after violating norms. Conversely, a stigmatizing order solidifies difference as an indelible defect, replacing the coordination of actions with the pure objectification of subordinates.
Haynes and Hickel: Hierarchy in the Service of Value Theory
According to Naomi Haynes and Jason Hickel, hierarchy is a central component of value theory. Values are inherently ranked—some are more important than others, creating a framework for the moral organization of the world. In this context, an egalitarian hierarchy is not a contradiction; it describes systems where ranks are accessible to everyone through formation and discipline, rather than being derived from an inherent nature.
The Care Threshold Test: A Metric for the Ethics of Social Systems
To assess the moral quality of a system, we apply the care threshold test. It examines whether institutions of mediation exist within the structure to guide a wrongdoer toward reintegration. Pathology begins when degradation becomes exclusionary. The procedural conditions for rationalizing hierarchy require the system to justify status through the language of reason and allow for open criticism of power mechanisms.
Flores: Inculturation Redefines the Adat Order
On the island of Flores, the traditional adat order constitutes a holistic whole. However, the process of Catholic inculturation often becomes a one-sided annexation that reduces agentic rituals to mere ornaments. If religion does not create channels for equal mediation but instead forcibly transfers concepts into foreign semantic frameworks, this hierarchy becomes stigmatizing for the local community.
Vertical Love: The Foundation of Ethiopian Orthodoxy
In Ethiopian Orthodoxy, the relationship with the sacred is based on vertical love. This is an asymmetric bond where authority is coupled with selfless care, modeled after the figure of Mary. Here, subordination is not a defect but a guarantee of protection, provided that mechanisms of mediation are functioning.
The Ngadha System: Ritual Degradation Stabilizes Structure
Among the Ngadha people, ritual degradation (nuka nua) serves to protect the classification system through the symbolic death of the offender's status. Though harsh, it stabilizes the structure as long as it does not permanently block paths for return. In contrast, the dawat ethics (inviting to faith) in Pakistan builds spiritual rank (darja) not through blood, but through sacrifice and discipleship, shaping the subject as both a giver and receiver of knowledge.
The Epistemology of Hierarchy: Contrasts Between Asia and Africa
In East Asia, hierarchy serves a teleological function—it organizes aspiration and self-improvement (the virtue of li). In Africa, the foundation is nurturing relationality (ubuntu), where seniority represents a genealogy of transmitted good. Europe, meanwhile, perceives hierarchy as a source of conflict between equality and dignity, attempting to rationally justify axiological differences.
The Americas: The Performative Dimension of Social Hierarchy
In the US, hierarchy is performative—rank depends on success, making those at the bottom solely responsible for their position. In Latin America, paternalism dominates, where value is "granted" from above. In India, the caste system links hierarchy to purity and a symbolic function relative to the whole, though migration and education are dynamically transforming these traditional ranks.
The Logic of Sacrifice: A Mechanism of Semantic Discontinuity
The logic of sacrifice reveals that rank requires semantic discontinuity—a ritual destruction to make the difference legible. Today, globalization creates a planetary hierarchy of aspiration, where recognition algorithms build new "digital castes." The wealth of the North is seen as a virtue, while the poverty of the South is viewed as a fault, proving that hierarchy does not disappear but merely shifts its language to the technological.
Summary
In a world striving for equality, have we forgotten the value inherent in aspiration and care? The key to harmony is not the elimination of hierarchy, but its transformation into a system that uplifts and protects. The anthropology of values teaches us that an inclusive hierarchy, linking rank with responsibility, is the foundation of care for our shared world. Are we ready to reinterpret an order where difference becomes an obligation rather than a reason for exclusion?
📄 Full analysis available in PDF