Introduction
Richard Rumelt, a leading thinker in modern management, defines strategy as a discipline of practical reason, rather than the poetics of ambition. In a world dominated by empty declarations, his approach restores rigor to conceptual work. From this article, you will learn why most strategic documents are useless "fluff," how to build the kernel of a good strategy, and why the ability to say "no" is more important than multiplying goals. You will discover the mechanisms that allowed giants like Apple and Walmart to succeed, and how Hannibal utilized strategic leverage at Cannae.
The Kernel of Strategy: Diagnosis, Guiding Policy, and Coherent Actions
According to Rumelt, a good strategy is a logical construction based on three elements. The first is a diagnosis—an act of cognitive asceticism that reduces the chaos of reality to a few key relationships. It allows for the identification of the organization's bottleneck. The second element is the guiding policy: the principles that set the direction for confronting the challenge, limiting the field of maneuver in favor of concentrating strength.
The third pillar is coherent actions. Unlike a bad strategy, which offers a "hodgepodge" of conflicting priorities, a good strategy designs a sequence of steps that are mutually reinforcing. Bad strategy avoids difficult choices, masking a lack of thought with jargon (so-called fluff) and mistaking goals for the path to achieving them. This often stems from the psychology of avoidance—a fear of conflict and the need for quick cognitive closure.
Strategic Leverage and Proximate Objectives
The essence of strategy is creating an advantage where none existed before. Strategic leverage involves imposing a structure on a situation where the opponent's resources become useless. A classic example is Hannibal at Cannae. Through precise coordination and anticipation of enemy movements, he transformed Roman numerical superiority into a deadly trap. This is a study of the opponent's institutional entropy, where they were deprived of the space to fight.
Effective strategy operates on proximate objectives. These are more effective than abstract visions because they focus on problems the organization is realistically capable of solving at a given moment. These objectives build a bridge between diagnosis and action, eliminating strategic drift. In this view, strategy functions as a justification procedure—it allows one to understand why a specific path was chosen at the expense of others.
Chain-Link Systems and Isolating Mechanisms
Many organizations operate within chain-link systems, where total performance is limited by the weakest link. Walmart's strategy illustrates this perfectly: success does not stem from low prices alone, but from a coherent architecture of logistics, data, and location. This creates an isolating mechanism—competitors cannot copy a single element without changing their entire system, which is blocked by the inertia of their own culture.
Similarly, Apple under Jobs' leadership performed a brutal reduction of its product line, focusing on concentration and building an economy of options. In the public sector, such an approach faces barriers: abandoning goals is politically costly, which forces the use of fluff as "systemic immunology." However, in the era of narrative overload and AI, only entities capable of honest diagnosis and rejecting trendy buzzwords in favor of hard action designs will survive.
Summary
A good strategy acts like a magnifying glass, focusing the organization's scattered energy into a single, burning point. However, this requires epistemic honesty and the courage to acknowledge that not everything is possible. True strength is born from a painful narrowing of the field of action and a precise architecture of cooperation. Can your organization reject the illusion of unlimited possibilities to find real effectiveness through the rigor of thought? Success in a non-linear world today depends not on the resources you possess, but on the ability to design coherent responses to the most difficult challenges.
📄 Full analysis available in PDF