Introduction
Postmodernism has evolved from academic skepticism into the foundation of contemporary activism. This article analyzes how the idea of incredulity toward metanarratives has transformed into "new orthodoxies," such as queer theory or critical race theory. We will also examine the specific Polish reception of these trends, where rigorous debate often gives way to political instrumentalization. You will learn how to preserve reason as a common good in a world dominated by identity-based dogmas.
Lyotard, Reification, and the Dismantling of the Canon
Jean-François Lyotard defined postmodernism as incredulity toward metanarratives—universal stories of progress and reason. However, this initial radical skepticism eventually underwent reification. Abstract concepts of deconstruction began to be treated as objective facts, leading to the rise of Social Justice Scholarship.
In this movement, postcolonial theory exposes "orientalism" as a discourse of power, aiming to decolonize science and validate local knowledge. Judith Butler introduced the concept of gender performativity, arguing that gender is not an essence but a constantly performed act. Meanwhile, Critical Race Theory (CRT) posits that racism is a systemic phenomenon and race is a social construct, challenging the liberal idea of "colorblindness."
Intersectionality, the Social Model, and the Limits of Science
A key tool of contemporary analysis is intersectionality. It allows us to see the overlapping axes of discrimination, such as race, gender, or class. In the field of disability, the social model achieved a breakthrough: the environment and architectural barriers, rather than bodily dysfunctions, were recognized as the source of exclusion.
Similar tensions arise in fat studies, where the struggle for the dignity of obese individuals clashes with medical data regarding public health. The authors of "Cynical Theories" warn that these theories can lead to the erosion of objectivity. When subjective experience becomes more important than falsifiable evidence, science and law lose their universal character, turning into systems immune to criticism.
Polish Reception: Between the Church and Politics
In Poland, the reception of postmodernism is often superficial and parochial. The Catholic Church has reduced complex theories to the figure of "gender ideology," seeing them as a threat to Christian anthropology. Polish politicians instrumentalize these concepts, using them as ammunition in culture wars, which diverts attention from real systemic problems.
Polish universities often choose a tactical retreat, hiding behind procedures instead of engaging in open debate. Meanwhile, Nancy Fraser calls for a synthesis of the politics of recognition with the politics of redistribution. A struggle over language alone cannot replace economic justice. Without grounding theory in the local context—such as the experience of the partitions or the post-1989 transformation—we will remain merely passive importers of Western disputes.
Scientific Integrity: Escaping the Ideological Trap
To break the impasse, we must demythologize language and restore a culture of rigorous academic debate. We need education in the genealogy of ideas and the courage to question the limits of dogmatism. The key to success is irony and distance toward one's own beliefs, which protect against fanaticism.
In the pursuit of sensitivity, will we lose the capacity for critical thinking? In the name of social justice, will we create new dogmas as oppressive as those we seek to overthrow? Or perhaps it is in the constant balancing between these extremes that the chance for a truly open and just world lies?
📄 Full analysis available in PDF