Meaningless Work: An Analysis of Managerial Feudalism and Meaning

Fundacja Dobre Państwo • January 10, 2026 • 🇵🇱 Polski

Introduction

The modern labor market is often a facade hiding managerial feudalism. In this system, the social value of a profession is inversely proportional to its economic valuation. This article exposes the mechanisms through which pointlessness becomes a proof of loyalty and the system enforces cynicism. You will learn how to distinguish useful work from make-believe work, why bureaucracy destroys our identity, and how Universal Basic Income (UBI) can restore our dignity. It is a call to build a new social contract based on real agency.

Bullshit Jobs vs. Shit Jobs: Feudalism and a Typology of Roles

David Graeber precisely distinguishes between two phenomena. Bullshit jobs are occupations that the workers themselves consider redundant (the test: what happens if the job disappears? Nothing). Shit jobs, on the other hand, are socially necessary (cleaners, nurses) but poorly paid and looked down upon. This wage paradox stems from a puritanical ethic: useful work is supposed to be its own reward, and thus does not require fair pay. Managerial feudalism drives this mechanism—a manager's prestige is measured by the size of their "entourage" rather than efficiency.

We can distinguish five categories of bullshit: Flunkies (exist for the boss's prestige

Summary

This article provides a profound analysis of the contemporary labor market through the lens of David Graeber's theory. The author exposes the façade of market pragmatics, pointing to the existence of "managerial feudalism"—a system in which bureaucracy and redundant processes serve to maintain hierarchy rather than efficiency. The text details the value paradox, a phenomenon in which jobs with the highest social utility are often the lowest paid, while the FIRE sector generates roles devoid of real purpose. The reader will learn about the typology of "shit jobs," including Lackeys, Thugs, and Supervisors, and understand mechanisms such as Goodhart's Law and the visibility regime. This is a critical look at the moral and political infrastructure of corporations, where suffering and loyalty to meaningless structures become the new determinants of professional virtue.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the difference between pointless work and shitty work?

Meaningless work is perceived by the performer as unnecessary, and its disappearance does not cause social harm. Bullshit work is socially necessary (e.g., cleaning), but poorly paid and low-prestige.

What is the paradox of values described in the text?

It is based on an inverse correlation: professions with the greatest social utility are financially valued the lowest, while opaque and unnecessary professions are rewarded with high wages.

Why might managers resist automation?

In managerial feudalism, prestige is derived from the number of subordinates. Automation, by reducing the team, strips the manager of a fragment of his identity and lowers his status in the power structure.

What roles are distinguished by the typology of managerial feudalism?

The text lists Lackeys (they build the boss’s prestige), Thugs (manipulation), Patchers (repairing flaws in the company’s architecture), Checkers (producing paper IDs) and Supervisors (unnecessary control).

How does Goodhart's law impact modern organizations?

It causes metrics (e.g., the number of audits) to replace real-world goals, creating a demand for experts in metrics and reporting rather than people who actually solve problems.

Introduction

Bullshit Jobs vs. Shit Jobs: Feudalism and a Typology of Roles

Frequently Asked Questions

Related Questions