Introduction
This article analyzes the mechanisms of power within female religious orders in Poland, where systemic abuse occurs under the guise of "holy obedience." Drawing on the testimonies of former sisters, we expose the reality hidden behind the walls: from the violation of the mind and economic exploitation to the lack of post-conciliar reforms. Readers will explore the structure of control that destroys women's identity and autonomy, and learn why this system persists despite its blatant contradiction of Gospel teachings. This is an analysis of spiritual colonization, where the body and conscience become the property of the institution.
Authority of Superiors and the Vow of Obedience: Mechanisms of Control
Power in religious orders is based on equating the superior’s will with the will of God. The vow of obedience becomes a tool for dismantling autonomy—a sister is expected to be an "obedient mechanism," carrying out orders without questioning their meaning. Mechanisms of exercising power include the surveillance of correspondence and the use of the secrecy of conscience for logistical oversight; confession is sometimes used as a tool to relay information to superiors.
Psychological and physical violence manifests in systematic humiliation (e.g., the necessity of asking for sanitary pads) and conditioning through food. Manual labor, such as scrubbing hallways with bare hands or painting a pigsty at night, serves as a means of discipline and exploitation, reducing nuns to cheap labor. The institution shields itself from criticism through institutional secrecy, imposing silence and treating any dissent as blasphemy against God.
Religious Dualism and the Cult of Suffering: Blocking Reform
A drastic religious dualism exists within the Catholic Church. While male orders embraced aggiornamento (dialogue, education, autonomy), female congregations have remained a "relic of tradition." Women are structurally excluded from decision-making processes—their lives are decided exclusively by men. The tabooing of sexuality and intimacy serves as a means of control; any touch is viewed with suspicion, and victims of harassment are often blamed for "participating in the sin."
The system legitimizes abuse through a cult of suffering. The theological metaphor of being a "doormat" teaches self-annihilation, turning pain into a tradable commodity in the economy of salvation. A lack of financial autonomy, the renunciation of wages, and the failure to pay social security contributions are elements of the reproduction of dependency. The ideology of mortification teaches sisters to hate their own needs, leading to the total suspension of their own will in favor of another's power.
Trauma and Life After the Habit: Reality After Leaving the Order
The process of leaving the community is a "quiet departure"—a ritual of erasure designed to protect the rest of the flock from the "infection" of doubt. Sisters vanish without a goodbye, often with a symbolic pittance instead of a severance. Trauma and exclusion are daily realities for former nuns: they struggle with depression, shame, and a lack of means to live. A conspiracy of silence ensures their stories are systemically erased from the community's memory.
Nevertheless, the stories of the protagonists in this reportage demonstrate the power of rebellion and the possibility of reclaiming agency. Dorota became a researcher, Iwona found her own voice, and Joanna and Magdalena run a hostel for those in need. Their life after the habit proves that leaving the system is the only way to reclaim dignity. Their rebellion was not an act of rejecting faith, but a defense of truth against an institutional lie that usurped the right to their consciences.
Conclusion: The Gospel vs. Religious Practice
The analysis reveals deep contradictions between Gospel teachings and the practice of religious life. While Christ offers freedom and friendship, the religious system often imposes bondage, fear, and degradation. Instead of mercy, sisters experience an ideology of sacrifice that destroys their talents and mental health. The stories of these women become a new testimony to truth and freedom.
In a world where obedience silences conscience and suffering becomes a commodity, can rebellion be the only way to reclaim one's self? Perhaps it is in abandoning false holiness that we find the true face of God, who desires human happiness, not self-annihilation.
📄 Full analysis available in PDF