Introduction
This article analyzes the phenomenon of ecclesial perfectionism—the drive to perfectly replicate the New Testament church model. John Mark Hicks identifies this as a blueprint hermeneutic, which replaces a living relationship with God with an obsessive fidelity to a technical pattern. Readers will discover how the rigorous logic of CENI shapes the psychology of faith and economic structures, and why transitioning toward theological hermeneutics is vital for the survival of authentic community in the age of algorithms and global markets.
Blueprint Hermeneutics and the Rigorous Logic of CENI
CENI logic (Commands, Examples, and Necessary Inferences) is a rationalist template that treats Scripture like a technical manual. In this system, the silence of the text becomes a categorical prohibition—the absence of a record regarding a practice implies its automatic exclusion. This approach, rooted in legal positivism, creates an aporia of the Church: if salvation depends on the perfect replication of a pattern, and no congregation possesses an infallible understanding of every detail, the community logically cannot exist. This ecclesial perfectionism destroys the assurance of salvation, building an "economy of fear" where grace becomes a theological oxymoron reserved only for the perfect.
The Mystery of Christ and the Primacy of Mercy over Sacrifice
John Mark Hicks proposes a theological hermeneutic that shifts the focus from the question "what does God require?" to "what story is God inviting me into?". The central category becomes the mystery of Christ—the cross and the new creation as the sole canon of faith. The principle of mercy over sacrifice redefines ritual: liturgical practices are significant only when they serve to restore relationships and bring healing. This is a transition from system logic (soulless rules) to the lived world, where meaning is born through communal dialogue. Although this shift triggers a fear of relativism, Hicks demonstrates that a rigid blueprint never ensured true unity; it merely masked divisions and institutional violence.
AI Algorithms and Prophetic Rationality in Business
Applying a blueprint hermeneutic generates real transaction costs: the paralysis of innovation and selective philanthropy limited to "one's own." Today, AI algorithms could automate CENI rigor, creating an inhuman system of digital doctrinal surveillance and spiritual ratings. The alternative is a new compliance standard in business and the Church, based on prophetic rationality. This rationality challenges market structures built on exploitation and debt, asking not about the formal correctness of procedures, but whether the operational model aligns with the logic of sacrificial love. In this view, business ethics becomes a form of theological expression rather than just a marketing ESG metric.
Summary
In the pursuit of an ideal replica of the past, will we lose the essence of the Gospel, which calls us to constantly read the signs of the times? A perfect liturgy devoid of the spirit of mercy becomes an empty ritual, far removed from Christ’s original message. It is time to break free from the illusion of control and trust the process of continually discovering God in a dynamic relationship with the world. The true measure of faithfulness is not a technical template, but the ability to embody the hope of the new creation in every dimension of social and economic life.
📄 Full analysis available in PDF