Capitalism on the Edge: Subversion and the Political Economy of Trust

• • Updated • 🇵🇱 Polski

This article examines Albena Azmanova's concept, which challenges the traditional view of capitalist crisis as a spectacular collapse. Instead, Azmanova proposes that capitalism has evolved into a state of permanent "shaking" in which crisis management has become the norm. This thesis prompts a shift in perspective: instead of asking why the system hasn't collapsed yet, we should examine how it transforms shocks into stabilization and the price we pay for it. Azmanova distinguishes between relational, structural, and systemic domination, exposing the hypocrisy of fighting for equality in a system that itself generates inequality. The crucial question becomes whether we strive for a fair distribution of the "poison" or for challenging the very logic of the system. Azmanova proposes a "way out through subversion"—the methodical elimination of capitalism as a regime of coercion while simultaneously preserving its economic functions. It is a call for radical pragmatism that places trust as the foundation of the political system, guaranteeing the material conditions of freedom and rejecting the blackmail of poverty.

Capitalism on the Edge: Subversion and the Political Economy of Trust

The Crisis of Crisis: The End of Capitalism's Cyclical Collapses

Modern capitalism is not standing on the edge of an abyss; rather, it persists in a state of permanent "jitteriness." Albena Azmanova diagnoses the crisis of crisis: a situation where shocks have ceased to be anomalies and have instead become a living environment and a technique of governance. Instead of awaiting a spectacular systemic collapse, we must understand its institutional metamorphosis. This article analyzes how the system processes its own instabilities into fuel for political stabilization and why traditional methods of resistance are losing their significance in the face of a new logic of domination.

Three Faces of Domination and the Paradox of Emancipation

Azmanova distinguishes three levels of power: relational domination (group asymmetry), structural domination (institutional rules), and systemic domination—the impersonal compulsion of competitive profit production. This shift exposes the paradox of emancipation: the struggle for inclusion and equal opportunity often only reinforces a model of life subject to market valuation. Currently, political conflict does not play out along the left-right axis, but rather along the line of opportunity vs. risk. For some, globalization is an ocean of possibilities; for others, it is a minefield destroying job stability and social security.

The Rich Uncle State in an Era of Mass Precarity

The evolution of the state has led to the emergence of the rich uncle state. Unlike the "nanny state," the uncle supports selected economic "champions," socializing risks while privatizing profits. The foundation of this arrangement is precarious capitalism, in which uncertainty becomes a mass experience, affecting even the educated middle class. Responses to these phenomena include regulatory attempts like the Platform Work Directive, which seeks to limit algorithmic power and the outsourcing of risk to the individual.

Subversion and the Political Economy of Trust

The solution is not revolution, but subversion—a "radical pragmatism" that changes the system's logic from within. The goal is a political economy of trust, guaranteeing material freedom from the blackmail of poverty. Key tools for decommodification include: cash benefits (requiring a tough fight against rent-seeking and monopolies), universal basic services, and shorter working hours. This project draws criticism: liberals fear a decline in innovation, while radicals accuse it of being overly procedural. Azmanova responds, however, that only institutional trust allows individuals to regain control over their own life trajectories.

A Coalition for Subversion: Unity in a Divided World

The chance for real change lies in a coalition based on the shared experience of precarity, uniting the interests of various social groups. However, we must avoid the trap of a "rich uncle state 2.0," which, under the banner of the "green transition," would continue to protect only the privileged. True subversion requires the institutionalization of claims for recognition and transparency. Will we manage to forge fear into the language of institutional interest, creating a foundation for systemic trust, or will we remain prisoners of a system that inherently undermines our security?

📄 Full analysis available in PDF

📚 Based on

Capitalism on Edge
()

👤 About the book's author

Albena Azmanowa

City, University of London

Albena Azmanova is a Professor of Political and Social Science at City, University of London. Her expertise lies in critical social theory and political economy. Her research spans democratic transition, critiques of capitalism, and the rise of populism. Notable works include 'Capitalism on Edge' and 'The Scandal of Reason'.

Mind map: Capitalism on the Edge: Subversion and the Political Economy of Trust

📖 Glossary

Dominacja systemowa
Bezosobowy przymus konkurencyjnej produkcji zysku, który narzuca logikę działania wszystkim uczestnikom rynku niezależnie od ich woli.
Państwo bogatego wujka
Model państwa wybierający rynkowych faworytów i wspierający ich w globalnym wyścigu, przy jednoczesnym przerzucaniu kosztów ryzyka na społeczeństwo.
Subwersja
Praktyka instytucjonalna uderzająca w logikę operacyjną systemu od środka, mająca na celu zmianę jego charakteru bez gwałtownej destrukcji form zewnętrznych.
Paradoks emancypacji
Sytuacja, w której walka o równość i inkluzję wewnątrz systemu wzmacnia jego opresyjną logikę poprzez akceptację rynkowych modeli sukcesu.
Ekonomia polityczna zaufania
Stan instytucjonalny gwarantujący materialną możliwość odmowy pracy wyniszczającej, gdzie bezpieczeństwo jest fundamentem wolności od szantażu nędzy.
Dekomodyfikacja
Proces ograniczania wpływu mechanizmów rynkowych na kluczowe sfery życia, takie jak zdrowie czy edukacja, poprzez zapewnienie do nich powszechnego dostępu.

Frequently Asked Questions

How does the current crisis of capitalism differ from those of the past?
According to Azmanova, the crisis has ceased to be a temporary event leading to change and has become a permanent environment and technique of governance, i.e. the so-called 'crisis of the crisis'.
What is the difference between relational and systemic domination?
Relational domination concerns the asymmetry of power between groups, while systemic domination is the impersonal compulsion to produce profit that governs all participants of the game regardless of their intentions.
Why can emancipation be paradoxically harmful to system change?
Because the fight for an 'equal seat at the table' often reinforces a model of life based on productivism and market value, rather than questioning the very logic of economic coercion.
What models of state does the author distinguish in systemic evolution?
The author points to a triad: the nanny state (protective), the stepmother state (neoliberal disciplining) and the rich uncle state (supporting selected corporations at the expense of the rest).
What are the main tools for building a political economy of trust?
Two families of tools are identified: monetary protection (e.g. minimum income) and universal basic services (health, transport, housing), which remove key needs from the market.

Related Questions

🧠 Thematic Groups

Tags:

More in: Szkatułka kosztowności

 Content is created by Fundacja Dobre Państwo.
Edited and published by APA ONE, the Foundation's own AI-based editorial system.