The ontology of heritage and relations with the past in light of the book 'Things We Found in the Ground' by Ellie Bruce

• • 🇵🇱 Polski

The article provides an interdisciplinary analysis of the status of the archaeological object, which the author reads not as a dead material resource with a specific market value, but as a dynamic weave of social, genealogical, and ethical relations. The main thesis of the text assumes that a monument is a carrier of memory and identity, requiring a radical redefinition of the concept of ownership in favor of responsibility for heritage (kaitiakitanga). The author confronts Western scientific paradigms—from Popperian falsificationism to Ostrom's theory of common-pool resources—with Maori relational ontology, in which objects are rooted in networks of whakapapa (genealogy) and mana. A key point of reflection is the necessity of separating the subjective, cultural experience of discovery from rigorous empirical verification. The text advocates for a transition toward participatory archaeology and the decolonization of knowledge, arguing that a true understanding of the past requires recognizing the multidimensionality of an object's value, which extends beyond formal rights of possession and technological material analysis.

The ontology of heritage and relations with the past in light of the book 'Things We Found in the Ground' by Ellie Bruce

Introduction

Is an artifact merely a dead object, or perhaps a living web of relationships? In her book Things We Found in the Ground, Ellie Bruce analyzes the status of the archaeological object as a carrier of memory and identity.

The reader will discover why the concept of ownership should be replaced by a notion of responsibility for heritage. The text confronts Western science with Māori relational ontology, highlighting the necessity of decarbonizing knowledge within archaeology.

The Archaeological Object as a Nexus of Matter and Relations

According to Ellie Bruce, an archaeological object differs from an ordinary thing in that it is not merely a material resource. It represents the intersection between physical matter and a system of social meanings that often fade over time.

The author emphasizes that the discovery of an artifact raises questions about the relationships between the discoverer, the community, and future generations. A metal axe serves as an example: while the material may survive for millennia, it does not automatically carry knowledge regarding the rituals of its former users.

In this view, the artifact ceases to be an object of possession and instead becomes an ethical obligation toward the past.

The Object as a Material Resource vs. an Element of Social Relations

Ellie Bruce distinguishes between treating an object as a resource (describing physical characteristics and market value) and perceiving it as an element of social relations. In the latter approach, history, provenance, and norms of access are paramount.

Such a perspective radically alters the interpretation of finds. Throughout its "biography," an object may transition through various statuses—from a tool to a gift, and finally to a museum exhibit—each of which assigns it a different value.

The author notes that ignoring the relational dimension reduces archaeology to a simple inventory of things, overlooking the social and cultural networks in which these objects once functioned.

Relational Ontology and the Māori Understanding of Connection

In the context of Māori traditions, Ellie Bruce points to the concepts of whenua (land/placenta) and whakapapa (genealogy). These shift the understanding of an artifact: it is not a remnant of a closed era, but rather an element of relational continuity.

Contrary to Western property law, the Māori employ the concept of kaitiakitanga. This is a responsibility for the guardianship of heritage that transcends administrative resource management and is rooted in ancestral bonds.

The author also analyzes pakohe material, demonstrating that its processing technology is a record of competence. She emphasizes that stone tools are not "inferior" to metallurgy, but rather represent an optimal adaptation to local conditions.

Summary

Ellie Bruce advocates for a transition toward participatory archaeology. This requires separating the empirical verification of data from the subjective, cultural experience of discovery, while maintaining respect for the knowledge of indigenous communities.

Can an object torn from the earth cease to be part of a living network of relations? The true value of an artifact lies in the tension between scientific evidence and the whispers of ancestors.

A key question remains: are we owners of the past, or merely its temporary custodians?

📚 Based on

Things We Found in the Ground

Sourcebooks, Inc.
ISBN: 9781464241833

👤 About the book's author

Ellie Bruce

Roman Found

Eleanor 'Ellie' Bruce (born c. 2000) is a British author, metal detectorist, and public history communicator based in Lincolnshire, England. She is best known as the co-creator of Roman Found, a popular digital media initiative and educational project established alongside her cousin Lucilla 'Lucie' Gray. Through Roman Found, Bruce documents their fieldwork discoveries, explores British material culture, and advocates for responsible, ethical metal detecting and amateur archaeology. She actively collaborates with heritage initiatives, recording historical artefacts through the British Museum's Portable Antiquities Scheme to assist regional historical preservation. Bruce's work making history accessible and promoting female participation in metal detecting has been featured across national media outlets, including The Guardian, BBC Breakfast, and ITV. She is the co-author of the 2026 memoir Things We Found in the Ground.

Mind map: The Ontology of Heritage and Relations to the Past

📖 Glossary

Ontologia relacyjna
Podejście, w którym byty nie są niezależne, lecz definiowane przez sieci wzajemnych zależności między ludźmi, przedmiotami i środowiskiem.
Whakapapa
Maoryski system genealogiczny, który łączy ludzi, naturę i duchowość w jedną strukturę powiązań międzypokoleniowych.
Kaitiakitanga
Tradycyjna maoryska koncepcja opieki i odpowiedzialności za zasoby naturalne oraz dziedzictwo kulturowe, wykraczająca poza prawo własności.
Taonga
Skarb lub rzecz cenna w kulturze Maorysów; może to być przedmiot materialny, ale także idea, język lub wiedza tradycyjna.
Whenua
Termin oznaczający jednocześnie ziemię i łożysko, symbolizujący głęboką, organiczną więź człowieka z miejscem jego pochodzenia.
Archeologia partycypacyjna
Model badań, w którym lokalne wspólnoty aktywnie uczestniczą w definiowaniu problemów badawczych i interpretacji znalezisk.

Frequently Asked Questions

How does an archaeological object differ from an ordinary material thing in terms of its meaning and ownership?
An archaeological object differs from an ordinary thing in that its meaning extends beyond market value and the category of individual possession, constituting communal heritage linked to history and place. It possesses a specific cognitive status because the material durability of the object is not equivalent to the preservation of the system of social meanings in which it originally functioned.
How does treating an object as a material resource differ from perceiving it in terms of social relations, and how does this affect the interpretation of archaeological finds?
The difference lies in the fact that treating an object as a material resource focuses on its physical characteristics and exchange value, whereas perceiving it through the prism of social relations links the object's meaning to its history, origin, and cultural norms. In archaeology, this means that the same object could have served different functions in different periods, e.g., as a tool, a gift, or an antiquity.
In what way do Maori concepts of land and genealogy change the understanding of an archaeological object?
Thanks to the concept of whakapapa, an archaeological object is not treated merely as a remnant of a closed era, but as an element of relational continuity and intergenerational community bonds. This changes the understanding of the artifact, giving it meaning derived from its participation in history and enduring ties with ancestors.
How do Maori concepts of relations with objects and land differ from Western legal and religious categories?
Maori concepts are based on notions such as mana (power and authority), tapu (sacredness and protection), and mauri (the life principle), which are not simple equivalents of European categories. Unlike the Western division into religious, legal, and economic spheres, traditional Maori normative systems combine these dimensions, allowing objects to function simultaneously in ownership, ritual, and political relations.
How does the Maori concept of heritage care differ from the Western understanding of ownership and resource management?
The Maori concept of kaitiakitanga is based on responsibility embedded in genealogical, cultural, and spiritual relations, extending beyond the framework of individual property rights or administrative management. In contrast to the Western understanding of resources, it encompasses not only the material protection of objects but also the care for traditional knowledge, practices, and bonds with the environment and ancestors.
What is pakohe, and how does archaeology study the process of creating tools from this raw material?
Pakohe is a hard rock (argillite) used by the Maori to produce tools, including toki adzes. Archaeology studies its production process as a multi-stage sequence of actions: from identifying the deposit and extracting the raw material (e.g., through thermal shock), through shaping with stones, to the final finishing of the tool.
How does archaeology study the process of creating stone tools, and is this technology inferior to metallurgy?
Archaeology studies the process of creating stone tools through use-wear analysis, experimental archaeology, and the reconstruction of the technological chain (chaîne opératoire). This technology is not inferior to metallurgy; the choice of material depended on local resources and the suitability of the solution, and both technologies could coexist and remain functional.
How do archaeological objects testify to social relations and the flow of materials between communities?
Archaeological objects testify to social relations through their circulation between communities as part of exchanges that build bonds extending beyond the economic value of things. The flow of materials, on the other hand, is evident in findings of raw materials far from their extraction sites, which, combined with technological and archaeometric analysis, allows for the reconstruction of distribution networks.
How can one distinguish scientific truth about an object from the personal and cultural experience associated with finding it?
One must separate the personal and cultural significance of the event from verifiable findings regarding the origin and chronology of the object. The intensity of the experience is not a criterion for historical truth, and determining the observable properties of material reality requires the application of verification methods.
How can contemporary archaeology combine scientific rigor with respect for the agency and knowledge of indigenous communities?
Archaeology can combine scientific rigor with respect for indigenous communities by applying participatory methodologies and critically analyzing power relations. This requires a clear distinction between empirical data and community memory transmissions, as well as including representatives of these groups as competent participants in the process of knowledge creation.

Related Questions

🧠 Thematic Groups

Tags:

More in: Szkatułka kosztowności

 Content is created by Fundacja Dobre Państwo.
Edited and published by APA ONE, the Foundation's own AI-based editorial system.