Introduction: Swollen Finance and the Collapse of the Old Paradigm
This article examines the phenomenon of "swollen finance," which Adair Turner defines as the process by which the financial sector transforms into an autonomous subsystem that dominates the real economy. For decades, mainstream economics accepted the rapid growth of private debt—which in developed countries surged from 50% to 170% of GDP. This occurred with the tacit acceptance of dogmas regarding market efficiency and rational expectations. However, the 2007–2008 crisis exposed the illusory nature of these assumptions, demonstrating that the unchecked expansion of finance leads not to stability, but to systemic fragility.
Speculative Credit and the Debt-Deflation Loop
The key to understanding instability lies in distinguishing between three types of credit. The first finances productive investment, the second funds consumption, and the third—which is overwhelmingly dominant—is used to purchase existing assets, primarily real estate. It is this speculative credit that generates dangerous debt, as banks have become machines for financing the competition for scarce spatial resources rather than supporting innovation.
When the bubble bursts, it triggers Irving Fisher’s debt-deflation mechanism. The euphoria phase transitions into panic deleveraging: the rapid fire sale of assets drives down their prices, which paradoxically increases the real burden of remaining obligations. According to Prof. Elżbieta Mączyńska, this erodes trust, the essential "lubricant" of the fiat system. When debt becomes an overhang, trust turns into a brittle shell masking systemic insolvency.
USA vs. EU: Choosing Between Debt and the Devil
The structure of the debt overhang varies by region. In the US, securitization dominates, dispersing risk through complex instruments and making it difficult to locate losses. In the European Union, the problem is the "doom loop" between banks and sovereign states—rescuing the banking sector drastically increases public debt, leading to stagnation and austerity policies.
Adair Turner presents us with a dilemma: choosing between debt and the devil. "Debt" refers to maintaining the current model based on private credit creation. The "Devil" is overt monetary finance—the creation of money by the central bank to meet the needs of the state. Although demonized as a source of inflation, it may be the only way to reduce the debt overhang without triggering a depression, provided there is full transparency and strict quantitative limits.
Artificial Intelligence and the New Logic of Instability
Modern financial architecture is being reshaped by artificial intelligence (AI). While AI improves data analysis, it creates new systemic risks: model concentration and the potential for coordinated, erroneous algorithmic reactions to "black swan" events. Prof. Mączyńska warns that AI could become a tool for structural consumer manipulation, exploiting information asymmetry to pull individuals into a debt spiral.
The post-2008 era has seen a paradigmatic reorientation. New economics, represented by figures such as Thomas Piketty, indicates that wealth inequality fuels instability: the excess savings of the wealthiest seek an outlet in lending to poorer classes, laying the groundwork for future collapses. Debt is no longer treated as a neutral accounting entry, but as a focal point of intergenerational justice.
Summary: The Financial System as an Aporia
Contemporary financial capitalism appears as a structural aporia. Neoclassical logic assumed that financial expansion increases efficiency (P→Q); however, the facts prove that it merely generates vulnerability to crises (R→S). The only way out of this impasse is to reject the belief in the beneficial impact of the financial sector's unlimited expansion.
In a world where algorithms increasingly manage risk and create debt, has trust become merely a variable in an equation rather than the foundation of the economy? Perhaps it is time to redefine what we mean by development before the illusion of growth consumes the remnants of our collective future. Are we condemned to dance with debt, or will we dare to write a new choreography?
📄 Full analysis available in PDF