Contemporary manifestations of fascism and the limits of historical analogy in light of Jason Stanley's theory

• • 🇵🇱 Polski

The article serves as a methodological warning against the overuse of the term 'fascism' in contemporary political discourse, where it often becomes an emotional synonym for any manifestation of authoritarianism. The author posits that a reliable analysis of radical movements requires a strict separation of three levels: empirical diagnosis of facts, theoretical ideological interpretation, and normative ethical assessment. Using case studies from the USA, Hungary, and Italy, the text demonstrates that processes of autocratization (the institutional limiting of democracy) are not identical to fascisization (the implementation of a specific ideology of national rebirth). By referencing concepts from authors such as Cas Mudde and Timothy Snyder [or Federico Finchelstein], the author shows that contemporary movements may adopt a fascist symbolic and rhetorical repertoire ('wannabe fascism') without simultaneously striving to establish a full dictatorship. The text argues that only a precise distinction between populism, competitive authoritarianism, and neo-fascism allows for the actual identification of threats to democracy, while avoiding the trap of mechanical historical analogies.

Contemporary manifestations of fascism and the limits of historical analogy in light of Jason Stanley's theory

Introduction

Contemporary political discourse frequently overuses the term fascism, treating it as a synonym for any manifestation of authoritarianism. This is dangerous, as it blurs the distinction between radical populism and totalitarian ideology.

In this article, we analyze the limits of historical analogy based on the theories of Jason Stanley and other scholars. You will learn how to distinguish the processes of institutional democratic backsliding from the actual fascization of a state, using examples from the USA, Hungary, and Italy.

The Necessity of Separating Scientific Analysis from Political Rhetoric

Not every manifestation of authoritarianism can be labeled as fascism, as the term carries a strict ideological meaning. According to Jason Stanley, fascism relies on specific techniques: the mythologization of the past, the hierarchization of people, and the creation of a sense of collective grievance.

Equating every violation of democratic norms with fascism robs us of the ability to recognize movements striving for palingenetic ultranationalism, or radical national rebirth. An example is the distinction between ordinary nationalism and a project aimed at the total reconstruction of the community along hierarchical lines.

Cas Mudde's Categories as Tools for Precisely Distinguishing Radicalisms

To scientifically distinguish populist movements from fascism, Cas Mudde proposes an analysis of three elements: nativism, authoritarianism, and populism. The radical right may undermine pluralism without completely rejecting the principle of elections.

Fascism, however, utilizes populist mechanisms to achieve a broader goal—the establishment of a hierarchical national community. This allows us to separate populism as a method of constructing conflict (the people versus the elites) from a full fascist ideology, which seeks to abolish democratic competition.

Autocratization is an Institutional Process, Not an Ideological One

Autocratization is the gradual restriction of checks and balances on power, whereas fascization requires the implementation of a specific ideology. This process can be objectively measured using indicators such as those from the Varieties of Democracy (V-Dem) project.

In the USA, Donald Trump's movement sparks debate; although it employs the rhetoric of rebirth, it is not unequivocally fascist due to institutional resistance. Viktor Orbán's Hungary, on the other hand, demonstrates that autocratization can persist for years without necessarily leading to a full dictatorship—as evidenced by the electoral victory of the Tisza party in 2026.

Italy and the Fratelli d'Italia party show continuity with neo-fascism, but this does not signify a return to fascism. Democratic regression or judicial reforms are signals of weakening norms, not automatic proof of the establishment of a totalitarian system.

Summary

The survival of pluralism depends on durable institutional safeguards, not ideological labels. Modern systems may adopt a fascist symbolic repertoire (wannabe fascism) without striving for a full dictatorship.

The key challenge remains resilience against the slow erosion of norms. The line between legitimate reform and the dismantling of democracy is often nearly invisible until it becomes irreversible.

📚 Based on

How Fascism Works Jason Stanley

Random House
ISBN: 9780525511847

👤 About the book's author

Jason Stanley

University of Toronto

Jason Stanley (born October 12, 1969) is an American philosopher specializing in epistemology, philosophy of language, and political philosophy. He serves as the Bissell-Heyd Chair in American Studies at the University of Toronto and was formerly the Jacob Urowsky Professor of Philosophy at Yale University. Stanley earned his Ph.D. from the Massachusetts Institute of Technology in 1995. His influential early scholarship contributed to epistemology and formal semantics, notably through his defense of interest-relative invariantism and his work on practical knowledge with Timothy Williamson. In political philosophy, Stanley has achieved wide prominence for his critical investigations into how language and ideology shape power structures, democratic erosion, and authoritarian manipulation, particularly in his analyses of propaganda, education policy, and the mechanisms of fascist rhetoric.

Mind map: Contemporary Fascism and the Limits of Historical Analogy

📖 Glossary

Palingenetyczny ultranacjonalizm
Ideologia zakładająca konieczność radykalnego, narodowego odrodzenia po okresie rzekomego upadku lub degradacji wspólnoty.
Autokratyzacja
Proces stopniowego ograniczania demokratycznych cech ustroju poprzez legalne instytucje, a nie gwałtowne zamachy stanu.
Natywizm
Przekonanie, że państwo powinno należeć do osób uznawanych za rodzimych, a osoby obce są traktowane jako zagrożenie dla wspólnoty.
Autorytaryzm konkurencyjny
System polityczny, w którym istnieją formalne instytucje demokratyczne i wybory, ale warunki rywalizacji są systematycznie nierówne.
Integralność prawa
Koncepcja, według której prawo powinno być stosowane spójnie i sprawiedliwie, niezależnie od aktualnej tożsamości rządzących.
Democratic Backsliding
Zjawisko regresu demokratycznego, polegające na stopniowym osłabianiu norm i instytucji chroniących demokrację.

Frequently Asked Questions

Why can every manifestation of authoritarianism not be called contemporary fascism?
Equating every manifestation of authoritarianism with fascism leads to a loss of the ability to recognize the specific characteristics of movements actually based on the ideology of national rebirth and community hierarchization. It is essential to separate scientific analysis from the rhetorical use of this term as a synonym for political evil, intolerance, or nationalism.
How can contemporary populist and radical movements be scientifically distinguished from fascism?
This distinction is based on the analysis of the program, the attitude toward democratic competition, and the way the national community is defined. It is crucial to separate populism and the radical right—which may undermine pluralism but accept elections—from fascism, which rejects democracy in favor of a hierarchical community and a radical restructuring of the system.
What is the difference between the process of autocratization and fascisization, and how can it be objectively measured?
Autocratization concerns the quality of institutions and the limitation of democratic control over power, whereas fascisization additionally includes the strengthening of ideologies and practices characteristic of fascism. This process can be objectively measured using multidimensional databases such as the V-Dem project, which employs a system of indicators regarding elections, freedom of expression, and institutional independence, among others.
Can Donald Trump's movement be unequivocally classified as fascist?
Classifying Donald Trump's movement as fascist is not straightforward and requires an analysis of institutional actions and organizational mechanisms, rather than rhetoric alone. This movement constitutes a broad coalition of various circles, and the assessment of its character is based on examining, among other things, its attitude toward constitutional procedures, relations with the media, and the way political opponents are defined.
Do current autocratic tendencies in the USA already signify the establishment of a fascist system?
No, current tendencies do not signify the establishment of a fascist system, as there is a fundamental difference between the process of autocratization and a full monopoly of power. In the USA, check-and-balance mechanisms still function, such as independent courts, competitive elections, pluralistic media, and a strong civil society.
How can contemporary populist movements utilizing fascist elements be distinguished from an actual system of fascism using examples from the USA and Hungary?
These movements may adopt elements of the fascist repertoire, such as xenophobia, propaganda, and political violence, but they do not achieve a full dictatorship. In the case of the USA, it is key to combine ideological analysis with the study of autocratization, whereas in Hungary, the differences are evident in the lack of scale of repression and racial ideology characteristic of historical fascism.
Does the case of Hungary confirm the inevitability of the transition from populism to dictatorship?
No, the case of Hungary does not confirm the inevitability of the transition from populism to dictatorship. The victory of the Tisza party in the April 2026 elections proves that the electoral mechanism has retained the ability to bring about a real change in power even after many years of dominance by a single group.
What is the connection between the contemporary Brothers of Italy party and historical fascism?
The contemporary Fratelli d'Italia party originates from the historical genealogy of post-fascism. Its roots are linked to the post-war Italian Social Movement (MSI), created by supporters of fascism, and the subsequent National Alliance (Alleanza Nazionale).
Must a party originating from a neo-fascist movement be automatically considered fascist?
No, organizational and symbolic continuity does not necessarily mean full ideological invariance, as a party may change its program and political practice over time. A reliable assessment therefore requires a comprehensive analysis of historical genealogy, programmatic documents, the composition of elites, and actual decisions made while in power.
Do the efforts of a government with neo-fascist roots to reform the judiciary and the recorded democratic regression in Italy signify a return of fascism?
Attempts to reform the judiciary and the recorded democratic regression are not evidence of the return of fascism, as democratic systems can adopt various structural solutions. The rejection of proposed changes in a referendum shows that institutional disputes can be resolved using effective democratic procedures.

🧠 Thematic Groups

Tags:

More in: Szkatułka kosztowności

 Content is created by Fundacja Dobre Państwo.
Edited and published by APA ONE, the Foundation's own AI-based editorial system.