The geopolitics of hegemony and the limits of political exceptionalism in light of Benjamin Moser's analysis

• • 🇵🇱 Polski

The article provides a multidimensional analysis of the mechanisms of hegemony in international relations, using the Israeli-Palestinian conflict as a lens to examine the tension between material power and the legitimacy of authority. The author posits that the true legitimacy of great powers and national sovereignty does not derive from military or economic superiority, but from the subordination of force to the norms of international law and responsibility for the dignity of another human being. Through a synthesis of political realism, institutionalism, and constructivism, the text demonstrates that arbitrary dominance is strategically shortsighted and ethically unjustifiable. By analyzing the strategies of the USA, China, Russia, and the EU, the author shows that a lasting order cannot be imposed from above by a hegemon, but requires the recognition of the agency of local actors and the rejection of the instrumental treatment of history and suffering for geopolitical purposes. Consequently, the text advocates for a transition from hegemony understood as control to hegemony understood as responsibility for creating conditions in which human rights constitute an impassable boundary for any power.

The geopolitics of hegemony and the limits of political exceptionalism in light of Benjamin Moser's analysis

Introduction

This text analyzes the mechanisms of hegemony and the limits of political exceptionalism, using the Israeli-Palestinian conflict as a case study. The reader will discover why the material power of great powers does not always translate into lasting peace.

The analysis is based on a synthesis of realism, institutionalism, and constructivism. Benjamin Moser, in his book Anti-Zionism: A Jewish History, along with the cited theorists, examines the tension between raw power and the legitimization of authority in light of international law.

Hegemony as the Ability to Shape Systemic Rules

Benjamin Moser and geopolitical analysts distinguish mere military superiority from actual hegemony. The latter is not simply a dominance of force, but the ability to impose the rules of system operation, institutional standards, and the frameworks used to justify the legitimacy of actions.

The US-Israel relationship serves as an example. While Washington provides military support, true hegemony requires diplomatic authority. Without it, a superpower may possess vast resources but remain unable to convert them into sustainable political outcomes, leading to phenomena such as moral hazard or entrapment.

Asymmetry of Capabilities and the Limits of Superpower Effectiveness

Military and diplomatic superiority does not guarantee a resolution to conflict because superpowers often ignore the agency of local actors. Benjamin Moser points to the asymmetry between Israel's strong state apparatus and the political fragmentation of the Palestinians.

The effectiveness of great powers is limited by a lack of trust and the problem of credible commitments. Even theoretically beneficial agreements fail when parties fear a shift in the balance of power. Consequently, global powers cannot act in isolation; they depend on regional intermediaries (e.g., Egypt or Qatar) who possess unique knowledge and connections.

The Limitations of Realism and the Role of Institutions in Legitimizing Power

Power alone does not create a stable order, as it lacks legitimacy. Political realism explains the motivations of great powers (e.g., China's pursuit of energy stability or Russia's multipolar maneuvering), but it does not justify the violation of legal norms.

The European Union employs the normative power Europe model, influencing the world through regulations and law rather than military force. However, technocratic assistance cannot replace actual sovereignty. Benjamin Moser suggests that lasting peace requires a transition from the management of force to the protection of human dignity, where human rights constitute an inviolable boundary for any power.

Conclusion

The true political maturity of great powers is revealed in their ability to voluntarily set limits on their own power in the name of the dignity of others. Dominance based solely on force is strategically shortsighted.

The question remains whether the contemporary security architecture can evolve from a system of control into a system that protects agency. The ultimate measure of civilizational progress is not the reach of one's influence, but the respect for human rights over national narratives.

📚 Based on

Anti-Zionism A Jewish History

Doubleday
ISBN: 9780385551250

👤 About the book's author

Benjamin Moser

Benjamin Moser (born September 14, 1976) is an American biographer, critic, and translator. Born in Houston, Texas, he studied history at Brown University before earning an M.A. and Ph.D. from Utrecht University in the Netherlands. Moser is widely recognized for his biographical and translation work focused on Brazilian novelist Clarice Lispector, including his groundbreaking biography Why This World (2009), for which he received Brazil's State Prize for Cultural Diplomacy. In 2020, he won the Pulitzer Prize for Biography for Sontag: Her Life and Work, an exhaustive study of the American writer and intellectual Susan Sontag. He has also explored Dutch Golden Age art history in The Upside-Down World (2023) and served as a contributing writer for publications including Harper's Magazine and The Nation.

Mind map: The Geopolitics of Hegemony and the Limits of Political Exceptionalism

📖 Glossary

Hegemonia
Zdolność państwa do wpływania na reguły funkcjonowania systemu międzynarodowego, standardy instytucjonalne i sposób uzasadniania prawomocności działań.
Moral hazard (pokusa nadużycia)
Sytuacja, w której sojusznik podejmuje ryzykowne działania, wiedząc, że koszty ewentualnej porażki zostaną przejęte przez silniejszego partnera.
Entrapment (uwikłanie)
Ryzyko wciągnięcia mocarstwa w konflikt zbrojny z powodu zbyt sztywnych zobowiązań wobec sojusznika, który sam sprowokował kryzys.
Realizm strukturalny (neorealizm)
Teoria zakładająca, że zachowanie państw wynika nie z intencji liderów, lecz z anarchicznej struktury systemu i nierównomiernego rozkładu potęgi.
Konstruktywizm
Podejście badawcze uznające, że relacje międzynarodowe są kształtowane przez tożsamości, normy i społeczne znaczenia, a nie tylko przez siłę militarną.
Stabilność hegemoniczna
Koncepcja, według której system międzynarodowy jest stabilny, gdy dominuje jedno mocarstwo dostarczające globalne dobra publiczne, np. bezpieczeństwo szlaków handlowych.

Frequently Asked Questions

How does actual great power hegemony differ from mere military superiority in the context of global order?
Hegemony differs from mere military superiority through the ability to influence the rules governing the international system, institutional standards, and the structure of economic benefits. While military superiority does not guarantee diplomatic authority, hegemony encompasses the capacity to justify the legitimacy of specific actions and to transform power resources into concrete results.
1. Why does the military and diplomatic superiority of great powers not guarantee an effective resolution to the Israeli-Palestinian conflict?
2. The superiority of great powers does not guarantee a solution to the conflict because the ability to bring about an agreement is not identical to the ability to ensure its implementation. Great powers remain dependent on the decisions of local actors, the structure of regional threats, and the effectiveness of the administration responsible for implementing the arrangements.
3. Why are military power and alliances alone insufficient to create a stable international order?
4. Power is not enough because the durability of an order also depends on institutions that reduce uncertainty, as well as economic and technological links resulting from complex interdependence. Historically shaped identities, norms, and social meanings attributed to the actions of other states are also key.
5. What is the difference between ordinary military dominance and actual hegemony in international relations?
6. Military dominance is merely the ability to exert pressure, whereas actual hegemony also includes establishing rules and beliefs presented as universal. Hegemony is a relationship between power and legitimacy, requiring institutional and cultural justification of the great power's position.
7. How does United States policy in the Middle East balance supporting Israel's security with striving for regional stabilization and the rights of Palestinians?
8. The United States treats Israel's security as an overriding goal, achieving it through military support and diplomatic pressure. Simultaneously, they strive to stabilize the region, among other things, through plans to end the conflict in the Gaza Strip and by linking the possibility of Palestinian self-determination with specific reforms and progress in reconstruction.
9. What are the risks and motivations of the great powers (USA and China) in their involvement in the Middle East?
10. The USA is motivated by the need to protect communication routes and deterrence; however, the risks include high costs of engagement and disputes over resource allocation in the face of rivalry with China. China seeks to ensure energy security, maritime transport, and trade stability, basing its actions on economic and diplomatic potential.
How do China position themselves in the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, and does their rhetoric on sovereignty align with their actual interests?
China officially advocates for state sovereignty, multilateralism, and a two-state solution, emphasizing the role of the UN. In reality, this rhetoric serves to build credibility with the Global South, while real decisions may be determined by economic interests, energy security, and relations with other great powers.
What is Russia's role and strategy in the Middle East conflict, and how does it relate to the norms of international law?
Russia's strategy is based on striving to maintain its great power status and limiting US global dominance by maintaining independent diplomatic channels with various parties to conflicts. In diplomatic practice, Moscow seeks to retain influence over negotiations, avoiding the complete blocking of international processes while simultaneously raising objections. Regarding legal norms, however, there is a tension between Russia's declared commitment to sovereignty and the inviolability of borders and its actions toward Ukraine.
How does the European Union influence international relations, given that it possesses neither a unified army nor the classic command structure of a nation-state?
The European Union influences international relations primarily through its regulatory, economic, and financial power, shaping legal and institutional standards (the so-called Brussels effect). Unlike traditional military hegemony, its influence is based on civilian instruments, which makes it less effective in situations requiring rapid military action.
Is the European Union's institutional and technocratic assistance in the Israeli-Palestinian region equivalent to building actual state sovereignty?
No, this assistance is not equivalent to building actual sovereignty, as there is a fundamental difference between developing institutional capacities and real agency. Expert and technocratic aid may increase the organizational efficiency of an administration, but it cannot replace political legitimacy or the competencies necessary to exercise power.
Why are global powers unable to resolve conflicts in the Middle East on their own without the participation of regional states?
Global powers depend on regional states because they possess unique economic, military, and diplomatic resources, as well as a credibility in local contacts that cannot be replaced by military pressure. Regional players play a key role as intermediaries whose knowledge of local institutions and ability to mediate between adversaries are essential for achieving specific political goals.
Why do financial aid and technical diplomatic agreements alone not guarantee lasting peace in the Middle East?
The durability of peace depends on internal political legitimacy, the consideration of regional participants' interests, as well as the social memory of conflict and expectations regarding self-determination. Technical solutions alone are insufficient without recognizing the actual structure of political and economic incentives and rebuilding institutions, legal systems, and social relations.
How does foreign funding for the reconstruction of the Gaza Strip affect the sovereignty and agency of its inhabitants?
Foreign funding carries the risk of long-term financial dependence, which may limit budgetary autonomy and the ability to pursue policies aligned with the preferences of the residents. An excessive concentration of competencies in the hands of external entities can lead to the restriction of actual Palestinian political agency.
Why are the parties to the conflict unable to reach a lasting agreement, even when it is theoretically beneficial?
The parties cannot reach a lasting agreement due to problems with private information, difficulties in making credible commitments to future actions, and the indivisibility of the objects of dispute. Additionally, they fear that the implementation of agreements will shift the balance of power, allowing the opponent to unilaterally break the contract or leading to an irreversible weakening of their own position.
How do cultural attractiveness and historical narratives influence the legitimacy of political power in the context of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict?
Cultural attractiveness and historical narratives shape social acceptance and the perceived legitimacy of policy, allowing for influence over other entities without the use of coercion. In the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, competing narratives and symbols serve to build credibility in global debate, although they may be instrumentally used by powers to perpetuate power hierarchies.
Can the political effectiveness of a great power justify ignoring legal and moral norms?
No, equating political realism with the belief that political effectiveness exempts a state from the obligation to respect law and morality is considered dangerous. Proper pragmatism does not consist in justifying actions that provide a momentary advantage, but in the honest recognition of their costs and long-term consequences.
What conditions and indicators determine whether a new political order is a real peace rather than just a ceasefire?
Real peace requires a precise definition of competencies, the duration of intervention, and the actual participation of residents in shaping the order, taking into account the right to self-determination. In addition to the reduction of violence, key indicators include: the actual protection of the civilian population, the fulfillment of obligations, access to public services, the functioning of the judiciary, administrative efficiency, and the possibility of conducting economic activity.
How can the analysis of Jewish identity and historical traumas help in understanding the mechanisms of legitimizing power in international law?
This analysis allows one to perceive when cultural traditions or historical sufferings are used as an unconditional justification for sovereignty and the legitimization of power at the expense of the rights of other people. It helps distinguish actual normative principles from the language of political legitimization, in which declarations about security or self-determination may serve the strategic interests of great powers.
How can technical theories of great powers be combined with the ethical requirement to respect human rights in the context of peace stability?
The strategic interests of great powers do not override existing norms for the protection of civilian populations, the right to self-determination, and limitations on occupying power. The consistent application of these universal norms is significant both morally and strategically, as it affects the durability of the political order and the conviction of system participants that it is not merely a tool of arbitrary domination.
What determines the actual legitimacy of the power of a state or community in relation to other people?
The actual legitimacy of power is not determined by military or economic superiority, nor by religious or national particularity. This legitimacy depends on linking power with responsibility and respecting basic human rights and the dignity of other people.

🧠 Thematic Groups

Tags:

More in: Szkatułka kosztowności

 Content is created by Fundacja Dobre Państwo.
Edited and published by APA ONE, the Foundation's own AI-based editorial system.